Cash-on-Cash Return (CoC) in Real Estate Proforma
Definition:
- Cash-on-Cash return (CoC) is a simple metric used to calculate the return on cash invested in a real estate project. It represents the annual pre-tax cash flow relative to the amount of cash invested.
How is it Calculated?
-
Formula:
-
Components:
- Annual Pre-Tax Cash Flow: The net income from the property after operating expenses and debt service.
- Total Cash Invested: The equity invested by the investor, which may include down payments, closing costs, and other upfront expenses.
Advantages:
- Simple Calculation: Easy to compute and understand for investors.
- Liquidity Focus: Highlights the actual return on the invested cash, emphasizing liquidity and cash flow.
- Good for Comparison: Provides a straightforward method for comparing different real estate deals.
- Focus on Pre-Tax Cash Flow: Gives a clear picture of what investors are earning in cash flow before taxes are considered.
Disadvantages:
- Ignores Time Value of Money: CoC does not consider how the value of money changes over time, unlike metrics such as IRR or NPV.
- Does Not Consider Appreciation: Fails to account for the property’s future value appreciation or depreciation.
- Pre-Tax Focus: As it doesn’t consider taxes, it may not provide an accurate post-tax return.
- Short-Term Focus: CoC focuses only on the short-term cash returns, ignoring long-term gains or losses.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Quick Snapshot: Offers a quick insight into how much cash flow an investor is generating on their initial cash investment.
- Useful for Cash Flow Properties: Ideal for investors who prioritize cash flow over appreciation or value-add projects.
Cons:
- Not Comprehensive: Fails to capture the full picture, such as appreciation, taxes, or the time value of money.
- Short-Term View: Does not account for the full holding period, long-term returns, or eventual exit strategy.
Shortcomings
- Static View: Provides a one-year snapshot without considering future cash flows or returns over time.
- No Risk Assessment: Does not evaluate the risk involved in achieving the projected cash flow.
- No Consideration for Leverage: While it accounts for debt service in the cash flow, it doesn’t measure how leverage might impact overall returns.
What is it Really Good For?
- Short-Term Investments: CoC is best suited for properties or projects where cash flow is the primary focus.
- Comparing Cash-Flowing Properties: Investors can quickly compare different investment opportunities based on immediate cash returns.
- Useful in Stabilized Properties: Ideal for properties that are already stabilized, providing consistent cash flow.
What is a Good Range for Cash-on-Cash Return?
- Industry Norms: A good CoC return varies based on market conditions but typically ranges between 8% to 12%.
- Higher for Value-Add Deals: For value-add properties where the goal is to increase cash flow over time, higher CoC returns may be expected.
- Lower for High-End Properties: In prime locations or high-end properties, CoC returns may be lower, as the investor is often relying on appreciation as well.
What Does it Mean for the Investor?
- Liquidity Indicator: Cash-on-Cash return tells investors how well their cash investment is performing in terms of liquidity.
- Focus on Cash Flow: For investors seeking cash flow over appreciation, CoC gives a clear picture of their earnings relative to what they’ve invested.
- Immediate Financial Health: Helps investors gauge the immediate financial health of a property and its ability to generate income.